Saturday, 23 November 2024

Tolkien about Heroic Fantasy

 


“One game to bring them in….and in the expansion, bind them!” The 1st edition base game and the Battles of the Third Age expansion

Some time ago I acquired a copy of the War of the Ring, at that time published by Fantasy Flight Games and the first edition. The game is now produced by Ares and is the second edition. It is a sprawling strategic campaign game set against the backdrop of the Lord of the Rings in the good guys have to unite in order to by time to beat the bad guys whilst the Fellowship makes it way to Mordor to destroy the ring. It is features cards for various actions within the game and best of all, nigh on 300 Bob Naismith designed figures representing the key characters and armies. In the first edition these have been moulded in a hard polythene, unlike the second edition which uses the same figures but moulded in a softer, more oily polythene.


Apologies for the poor quality of the pictures but these are taken from the rule book. Above you see the good guys whilst below are the forces of evil


Sadly the Battles of the Third Age does not include such a page but does see the addition of models representing Rohan captains (Theoden, Theodred and Eomer), Gondor captains (Faramir and Imrahil), Black Uruks, Southron horsemen, the Witch King, Corsair ships, Treebeard and the Ents, Half-orcs, Dunlendings, Galadriel, the Balrog and a dozen siege machines, six for each side - Towers for the forces of evil and Trebuchets for the bad guys. I will get some close ups of the figures in my next post.

Needless to say it was the figures that originally clinched it for me. The foot figures are roughly 25mm, the mounted slightly smaller, say around 20mm-ish. The Ents are around 35mm tall whilst the siege machines and Corsair ships do not really fit in with the figures at all as they are too small.

I had a plan about painting the figures (many owners of the game have done so) and using them for such things as HOTT, Dragon Rampant or even low level skirmishes. A bold plan given my aversion to painting but these figures would suit even my old-fashioned and amateurish painting style. They have nicely exaggerated detail that lends itself well to shading and highlighting and, to be frank, older eyesight!

To cut a long story short, an opportunity arose to acquire the only expansion that was available for the first edition - elements of which found their way into the second but not all. It was a little on the expensive side but in the interests of completeness I grabbed it and was hugely pleased that I did.

Battles of the Third Age is really two expansions in one as it expands the original game as well as providing two standalone battles - the Battle for Rohan and the Battle for Gondor. These two are effectively ‘games within a game’ and are a perfect way to get into the heat of the action quickly. As I recall the Lord of the Rings version of Risk had a similar idea with the expansion that included additional figures and a game based on the battle of Minas Tirith.

What does this all mean then?

Well, I still like the idea of using the figures outside of the original game but obviously, there would be shedload of painting to undertake first. Call it a long term slow burner then, unless something profound happens in the meantime!

Which of course it has….



The latest offering from Two Fat Lardies - and hugely impressive these rules look as well!


The rear cover
These will need more figures than for HOTT or Dragon Rampant but not excessively so in my opinion. I reckon that given the range of models available from the two War of the Ring sets I could easily raise a couple of forces that would be usable in a Tolkien/Peter Jackson style setting.

Oh well, another project to add to the list but, and it is a significant but, I have everything I need to complete it in terms of figures.

Meanwhile though, back to the ships (and not the Corsairs of Umbar!).


10 comments:

Mark Cordone said...

I bought the game with the idea of using the figures as well. I especially liked the elephants and have used them with my Risk Europe armies. They are, with proper prep, easy to paint. ( I soaked them in hot soapy water then double rinsed them). I'm looking forward to seeing what you do with them.

Steve J. said...

I've never heard of that game, but the figures do look nice. The latest TFL offering is gaining a lot of interest, but for my I'll simply stick with Dragon Rampant et al for my games, as I know the rules and they provide quick, fun games, the sort of thing we played as kids:)!

David Crook said...

Hi Mark,

Did you get the 2nd edition? There are some good figure expansions with this edition but for me I have more than enough at present to be going on with! I may try to rustle up the players to give it a go as a board game as it looks great fun.

I like the design of the figures as the exaggerated detail should make them easy to paint - even for little old hamfisted me!

All the best,

DC

David Crook said...

Hi Steve J,

They are certainly more detailed than DR and HOTT - both of which I really enjoy - but have some attractive ideas in them.

As for painting them I know I can do but it really will be tricky to manage the time required at present, particularly as I am knee deep in MDF!

All the best,

DC

Chris said...

I have been following the author of Midgard for several years now. I just got the pdf, and even though I did a quick first read, they look the like the perfect rules for Lord of the Rings battles.

Mark Cordone said...

Yes, and a couple of the expansions. I think they will prove useful for some 3x3 fantasy games. I use 1/72 figures for my RPGS, and some of these have proven useful for this as well.

Aly Morrison said...

Nice fluttering David…
What a lovely selection of figures you get….
I can see why you would want to use them for other games systems…

All the best. Aly

David Crook said...

I am in two minds about the second edition - only because I reckon I have more than enough for my needs with the first! There is certainly more than enough for any self respecting dungeon crawl though.

All the best,

DC

David Crook said...

Hi Chris,

They do look really good and have that all important ‘flavour’ about them.

All the best,

DC

David Crook said...

Hi Aly,

They are made from a hard plastic/polythene and were designed by Bob Naismith and are tempting even me to take up a paintbrush - who would have thought? ;-)

Meanwhile, back to the ships!

All the best,

DC